Toasted Coconut Cream Pie

coconut cream pie recipe

Toasted Coconut Cream Pie – Flaky pie crust filled with creamy coconut cream topped with whipped cream and covered with toasted coconut.

Did you have a fabulous 4th of July? We did. We had a nice relaxing weekend. We stayed inside a lot, due to the heat, but we needed the break. We have been running around like crazy people since we got to Kansas. The Army does a good job of celebrating the 4th. Their fireworks display was great. We were lucky enough to sit outside on our lawn with our neighbors and watch the show. Now, it is late in the evening, and I can hear the neighborhood fireworks still going off. I truly love the 4th of July.

coconut cream pie recipeSo do these little people. You know what else I love? Pie. And feeling all domestic-like when I make one. You know what else make else makes me feel all domestic-like? A cute kitchen apron from Shabby Apple. We will get to that later.

coconut cream pie recipeCoconut Cream Pie is one of the most heavenly creations imaginable. Next to apple pie, it is my favorite pie to eat. If it is on a restaurant menu, I cannot resist it. The thing is, that when coconut cream pie is good, it is so incredibly good. But, when it is not good, it is not worth the calories. There is nothing worse than ordering a piece of pie and expecting a light, coconut filling and getting a watery, vanilla pudding, with a hint of artificial coconut flavoring.

My goal was for this pie to taste like real coconut. This pie, uses real coconut milk, and lots of toasted coconut. Lots of coconut real flavor. A shot of Malibu or coconut flavored rum would be incredible in here as well. This pie seems like it would be complicated to make, but really it is very simple. I baked off the crust and started on the filling while it cooled.

By the time the crust was finished cooling, the filling was done and waiting in the fridge. I whipped some cream at the last minute, and garnished with toasted coconut. It was a piece of cake. Uh, I mean pie.

coconut cream pie recipe1 prebaked 9-inch pie crust

2 cups half and half
1 cup coconut milk
2 eggs
3/4 cup sugar
1/2 cup flour
1/4 teaspoon salt
1 cup toasted sweetened coconut (plus more for garnish)
1 teaspoon vanilla

whipped cream (I used about 1 1/2 cups heavy cream, 1 packet Whip-It, 1 teaspoon vanilla, and 3 Tablespoons sugar)

coconut cream pie recipeCombine the half-and-half, coconut milk, eggs, sugar, flour, and salt in a saucepan.

coconut cream pie recipeWhisk together. It will be pretty lumpy at this point. The flour will dissolve, and the coconut milk will melt into the half-and-half, I promise. Cook over medium-low heat, whisking constantly.

coconut cream pie recipeBring the mixture to a boil. It will come to a bubble and start to thicken.

coconut cream pie recipeAny time I make a pudding, custard, or ice cream base (basically, whenever I cook eggs) I like to push it through a strainer to make sure that it is really smooth and no little bits of cooked egg end up in my custard. I put my custard into an ice bath to chill it down faster, I was in a bit of a rush.

coconut cream pie recipeAdd the vanilla and the toasted coconut to the custard.

coconut cream pie recipePour the coconut custard into the cooled pie shell.

coconut cream pie recipePut a piece of plastic wrap directly onto the custard, and let chill in the fridge for 3 hours, the filling will firm up.

coconut cream pie recipeTake the pie out, and garnish with whipped cream and toasted coconut.

toasted coconut cream pie

Toasted Coconut Cream Pie

Yield: serves 8

Toasted Coconut Cream Pie - a rich and creamy coconut filling topped with whipped cream and toasted coconut.


  • 1 prebaked 9-inch pie crust
  • 2 cups half and half
  • 1 cup coconut milk
  • 2 eggs
  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 1/2 cup flour
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 1 cup toasted sweetened coconut (plus more for garnish)
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • whipped cream (I used about 1 1/2 cups heavy cream, 1 packet Whip-It, 1 teaspoon vanilla, and 3 Tablespoons sugar)


  1. Combine the half-and-half, coconut milk, eggs, sugar, flour, and salt in a saucepan.
  2. Whisk together. It will be pretty lumpy at this point. The flour will dissolve, and the coconut milk will melt into the half-and-half, I promise. Cook over medium-low heat, whisking constantly.
  3. Bring the mixture to a boil. It will come to a bubble and start to thicken.
  4. Any time I make a pudding, custard, or ice cream base (basically, whenever I cook eggs) I like to push it through a strainer to make sure that it is really smooth and no little bits of cooked egg end up in my custard. I put my custard into an ice bath to chill it down faster, I was in a bit of a rush.
  5. Add the vanilla and the toasted coconut to the custard.
  6. Pour the coconut custard into the cooled pie shell.
  7. Put a piece of plastic wrap directly onto the custard, and let chill in the fridge for 3 hours, the filling will firm up.
  8. Take the pie out, and garnish with whipped cream and toasted coconut.
Nutrition Information:

Amount Per Serving: Calories: 0Total Fat: 0g

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Travel Framed Photos Photo Collage

Oh hey there!

BakedBree was originally created by Boston-based blogger Bree Hester but is now run by a team of food bloggers with a passion for all things food. Here you can get lots of weeknight meal inspiration, eat more plant-based meals, and still indulge in a decadent sweet treat. Baked Bree is a place where you will find great recipes and inspiration for your next adventure.

raspberry orange pistachio ricotta cake slices on a wire rack

Don’t Miss a Thing!

The newsletter you can’t wait to read. Best enjoyed with a beverage and a snack.Β 

Enter your email address below to join my list and receive my weekly Friday newsletter and new blog posts.

New York Crumb Cake

This Post Has 289 Comments

  1. Emilie

    My favorite pie is key lime! πŸ™‚

  2. Emilie

    Fan of Shabby Apple on Facebook! πŸ™‚

  3. Emilie

    Fan of Baked Bree on Facebook! πŸ™‚

  4. Emilie

    I subscribed to the Baked Bree newsletter!

  5. Gessica

    That pie makes me want to bake right now!!!! It look wonderful! I’d have to say my favorite pie is chocolate cream!!

  6. Elisa B.

    My dad makes the most wonderful huckleberry pie. It has a cream cheese layer between the berries and its graham cracker crust. Mmmm! πŸ™‚

  7. Elisa B.

    I’m a fan of Baked Bree on FB.

  8. Elisa B.

    I’m a fan of Shabby Apple on FB.

  9. Rachael Adams

    My favorite pie is my grandmas apple but I’m going to have to make this one soon because it looks amazing!

  10. Jenn C.

    My favorite pie is the one that is made by someone else, preferably in their home. I am not a baking fan and I really like variety in food. I did however have a very deliciously creamy Key Lime Pie at an Amish restaurant in Sarasota, FL. Best fried chicken too!

    Thanks for doing this giveaway! I’d love to have a cool apron like this.

  11. Jane Capri

    mmmm looks yummy! i’m the only one in my house that loves coconut! my favorite pie is apple pie. but not just ANY apple pie. Apple pie from Julian California. It’s an old mining town in southern California and in my favorite shoppe up there, there are old ladies baking this in a kitchen. It’s taste is perfection!!! They are known for their pies and they are SERIOUSLY incredible…fresh with a bit of ice cream on top…..HEAVEN!

    1. Lisa Boyd

      Oh, I’m with you Jane!… I was passing through there last month and popped into the restaurant/shop and those pies were amazing! I only wish I could have tried them all. You are right though, the apple pie there ranked right up there with the apple pie my mom makes on her farm. Amazing! πŸ™‚

  12. Melanie

    Apple but pecan is a close second.

  13. Jeanne ODonnell

    My favorite pie is raspberry!

  14. Evelyn R

    My favorite pie is apple crumb.

  15. Evelyn R

    I am a fan of Baked Bree on Facebook

  16. Evelyn R

    I am also a fan of the Shabby Apple on Facebook

  17. Betsie

    I love pie! Who doesn’t? πŸ™‚ My favorite kind is blueberry crumb.

  18. Ann

    That coconut cream pie looks delicious! I’ve been majorly craving banana cream pie for about three months, hello random pregnancy cravings, and I think I can modify this to fit the bill!
    My all time favorite pie, though, is blueberry with vanilla ice cream. And I’d love a cute apron!

  19. Hannah

    Oooooh! What a yummy looking pie! Coconut cream is divine- I’ll have to give your recipe a whirl. Living close to the mountains, we have lots of wild berries, so I think my very favorite is huckleberry. Add a scoop of vanilla ice cream and a cup of coffee, and I am one happy camper! Of course, I would love to have a pretty Shabby Apple apron to serve it up in! πŸ™‚

  20. Sarah

    My favorite pie is peach pie with a lattice crust πŸ™‚

  21. Lynn G.

    Coconut cream is actually my favorite pie, so this recipe is especially sweet!

  22. Karen N.

    Fresh Cherry. Fresh Cherry. Fresh Cherry. That’s my favorite pie. Did I mention, “Fresh Cherry”?

  23. jamie

    I love Dutch Apple Pie (with a dash of cayenne, please!)

  24. jamie

    I have liked you on Facebook!

  25. jamie

    “liked” Shabby Apple on Facebook too!

  26. Leslie

    Blueberry and Banana is my favorite pie but I always love a good coconut!!

  27. alison

    Apple pie would have to be my favorite. Something about the changing leaves, scent of cinnamon and warmth of a sweater that makes the whole experience of an apple pie.

    I made a cherry pie yesterday for our 4th celebration with friends. My crust was not nearly as pretty as yours. I may need a few pointers there. Or maybe just a cute apron will do the trick?

  28. Lynn G.

    I am a Baked Bree FB fan.

  29. Lynn G.

    And… I also receive your fabulous newsletter and cookbook. Thanks!

  30. Diane Enloe

    You amaze me in how you have such a beautifully done blog. I am a retired military officer’s wife, so I know what it is to move…..and move…..and move! How you inspire women of all ages by what you say, by sharing your life and precious family with us, and for all the wonderful recipes and tips that you give! I am with many………coconut cream pie might very well may be my favorite pie……and yours looks delish!! I do have a recipe for an apple pie where I add a bit of apple juice to that has brought lots of compliments. With much appreciation for the life you live~


  31. Mabel

    My favorite pie is the old ol’ Apple Pie with vanilla ice cream! Yum. Can’t wait to make this delish coconut cream pie though.

  32. Bridgette

    I haven’t made pie in ages, but this makes me ready to put on my apron and get cooking. I LOVE coconut, so it’s off to the store to get supplies πŸ™‚

  33. Kelley {mountain mama cooks}

    Going to have to go with blueberry pie. Definitely my favorite! The apron is adorable!

  34. Kelley {mountain mama cooks}

    Already a fan of baked bree on facebook, thanks!!

  35. Jeanelle @ Glocal Girl

    MMmmmmmmmmmmm Peach pie πŸ™‚ (I know I’m in Amsterdam but I’m playing on behalf of my mother whom after meeting you is a huge Baked Bree fan!!)

  36. Jordan

    So hard to choose just one πŸ™‚ Pie is my favorite dessert hands down, I’d rather have a birthday pie than cake any day! I would have to say apple pie in the fall is just the best, especially still warm and paired with a scoop of ice cream! yummmm- although I must say, in the summer a cool coconut cream pie sure is tasty!

  37. jancd

    All pies are my favorite, but my very favorite is coconut cream. I never make it, but I love it. That apron would help me make it, I think.

  38. Lyndee

    I Love Lemon Meringue Pie! However, I have a serious weak spot for coconut. Love your blog!

  39. Jen N.

    What a great giveaway! My favorite kind of pie is pumpkin. I look forward to it every fall.

  40. Jami

    Coconut Cream is my favorite pie! The apron is adorable!

  41. Delila

    I love coconut pie, or pina colada pie.

  42. Delila

    im a BB fan on FB

  43. Delila

    im a SA fan on FB

  44. Karyn

    My favorite pie IS Coconut Cream Pie. There is a restaurant in Toronto – Scaramouche that makes THE best Pie. It is top secret. I even took a cooking class to see if they would part with the recipe. No Chance!! My husband and boys know how much I love it, they made me one for Mother’s Day. It was pretty good. I can’t wait to try your version Bree, thanks so much for this recipe. Karyn

  45. shannon

    sour cream apple in the fall, coconut cream in the summer…….and maybe fresh strawberry ……pie makes me happy. sometimes i will make as many as five different pies for a big family gathering. pie crust is kind of a sexy – in a june cleaver kinda way – thing to make πŸ™‚

  46. Cheryl

    My favorite pie is mixed berry with a crisp topping. Just wanted to let you know I missed seeing your beautiful family yesterday. All the best to you and yours!

  47. elizabeth

    warm apple pie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream!

  48. elizabeth

    i am a facebook fan of baked bree πŸ™‚

  49. Teri

    definitely key lime!

  50. Sarah @ pão e queijo

    I love Shabby Apple, too! Your pie looks amazing… my favorite pie has to be pecan pie, if it’s done right!

  51. Sarah @ pão e queijo

    I am a fan of Shabby Apple on Facebook.

  52. Sarah @ pão e queijo

    I am also a fan of Baked Bree on Facebook.

  53. Ashley

    Your pie looks delicious Bree! Well done πŸ™‚
    I would have to say my favourite pie would have to be Blueberry! Every year my dad goes to pick his own blueberries makes the most delicious pie EVER:)

  54. Molly McCullah

    Rarely do I meet a pie I do not like, but my favorite is Margarita Pie with a crushed pretzel crust.

  55. ellen patton

    I made a peach pie on Saturday that was delicious. But I think my favorite it chocolate cream pie. And I love love love aprons.

  56. Erin in IA

    Who could resist an all American Apple Pie. πŸ™‚ Yum…

  57. Melissa Jackson

    Pumpkin pie is my favorite. I think it’s partly because I only get it once or twice a year (at Thanksgiving and maybe at Christmas). Delicious!

  58. Kathryn

    Already a fan of Baked Bree on FB. =}

  59. Heidi

    I love pumpkin pie… always! My husband seems to think that you can only have pumpkin pie (and other related pumpkin goodies) between September and December, but I say it’s good ALL YEAR LONG!

  60. Kathryn

    Now a fan of Shabby Apple on FB. =}

  61. Kathryn

    Already subscribe to you newsletter!! Love all the goodies you share!!

  62. AZArdie

    My favorite pie is peach!

  63. Linda

    Looks yummy. Cute aprons rock. I’ve got a pink one with polka dots that I really love.

    Favorite pies? Blackberry, when it’s my dad’s simple recipe. Also buttermilk pie, but it’s hard to find a good one and I’ve never made it.

  64. Rita

    My favorite pie is pumpkin pie.
    rncstrong at gmail dot com

  65. Lisa Boyd

    Well seeing as I grew up on my family’s blueberry farm, I’m obliged to say blueberry pie is my favorite (of which I’ve had many delicious variations a la my mother) but secretly (between you and me), my “closet favorite” is a decadent chocolate cream pie! πŸ˜‰

  66. Jen C.

    Hmm tough choice. I guess I’d say lemon meringue just because the filling in the topping just go together so perfectly.

  67. Marissa

    My favorite pie is banana cream- or chocolate cream… too many to choose! πŸ™‚

    I will definitely try your coconut pie soon though!

  68. Shannon Kelley

    I’m a sucker for a caramel apple pie! Love your site!

  69. Hanna

    Peach!!! I love peach pie:)

  70. Hanna

    I am a fan of Baked Bree on facebook
    name is hanna porter villarrubia

  71. Hanna

    I am also a fan of Shabby Apple on facebook

  72. karin

    Cranberry Apple pie is very yummy.

  73. Sierra Gillham

    Banana Cream πŸ™‚

  74. Dandy

    I am so in love with their shop!

    I think my favorite might be banana cream, or coconut cream or maybe fresh peach.

    Or wait, chocolate cream.

    No coconut cream.

    Blueberry? ~sigh~ Is this a test? πŸ™‚

  75. Jess

    oh, i’d have to say ina’s frozen key lime pie – nothing beats it! so cold and tart, and with homemade whipped cream on top? i might have to make one right now πŸ™‚

  76. Michelle

    Peach pie! No cherry pie…no peach! It’s a tie πŸ˜‰

  77. Michelle

    I subscribe to your newsletter!

  78. Jess

    i subscribe to the baked bree newsletter, and…

  79. Michelle

    I am a fan on facebook!

  80. Jess

    i’m a baked bree fan on facebook, and…

  81. Jess

    i’m a shabby apple subscriber AND facebook, fan…trifecta!

  82. Susan

    Oh my goodness. I love pie more than cake so to choose one…but you asked for one. Immediately springing to mind is ‘lemon meringue’ because my grandmother got it into her head about 40 years ago that this was my favorite. She always made it when we visited, even if there were other things on the dessert menu. I didn’t complain & no one else did either.

    I love Shabby Apple, too, & somehow missed seeing the aprons. Adorable as everything they do. Therefore, I have already been a fan of theirs on FB for a longish time. I’ll subscribe to your newsletter but will have to do that & then come back.

    Thanks for the giveaway & for not putting so many instructions/demands in that it defies reason.:)


  83. Lynda Clark

    My favorite pie is lemon meringue. Thanks for this great giveaway, love the vintage looking apron. Shabby Apple makes the cutest stuff.
    [email protected]

  84. Susan

    OK, I subscribed to your newsletter. I am really enjoying looking at the recipes & photographs. Thanks for your efforts!

  85. Christina

    Though it may be really boring, no pie tastes quite as good as classic apple pie.

  86. Katherine

    Chocolate cream πŸ™‚

    katherinedibello (at) gmail (dot) com

  87. Jenn C.

    I’m an email subscriber already!

  88. Jenn C.

    I just became a fan of Shabby Apple on Facebook.

  89. Rebecca

    Cherry Pie!

  90. Rebecca

    IÒ€ℒm a baked bree fan on facebook

  91. Rebecca

    I subscribe to your newsletter

  92. Deirdread

    adorable aprons!! favourite pie… how to pick just one? i really love pecan pie, loaded up with a whipped topping — or better yet, a chocolate pecan pie! =)

  93. Deirdread

    i’m already a baked bree subscriber!

  94. Deirdread

    i’m a fan of baked bree on FB!

  95. Hilary

    Peanut Butter pie is my fav or French Silk! Yum Yum!

  96. Deirdread

    and am now a fan of Shabby Apple on FB! thx for the fab giveaway!

  97. vanessa delgado

    my favotrite kind of pie is a key lime pie.

  98. vanessa delgado

    i Like shabby apple on facebook

    fb name- Vanessa Delgado Mora

  99. Sarah

    Peach pie is the best ever!!!

  100. vanessa delgado

    i have become a subscriber to your newsletter and recieved the ebook.
    email subscriber @ [email protected]

  101. Aubrey

    Most definitely french silk..mmmmm!

  102. Sara

    Fresh strawberry!

  103. Julie

    Peanut butter pie is my fav!

  104. Cair

    Favorite pie is ice cream pie.

  105. Cair

    Liked Baked Bree on FB

  106. Cair

    Liked Shabby Apple on FB

  107. Cair

    Subscribed to Baked Bree

  108. Kelly P

    Pecan Pie for the win!

  109. Kelly P

    I’m a new email subscriber.

  110. Kelly P

    I liked you on FB

  111. Kelly P

    I also like Shabby Apple on FB

  112. Pam

    Lemonade pie, with vanilla wafer crust for summer and pumpkin pie for the fall months.
    Have bee a fan of bake bree for sometime now. Love the website.

  113. Heather Spooner

    My favorite kind of pie is Key Lime. Thanks for the giveaway!

  114. Samantha Jean

    Oh – this is a hard one. Pies and ice-cream are my two favorite types of desserts. It’s hard to choose one flavor out of each that I like more than another. I love fall flavors of anything – so I’m definitely going with pumpkin & apple. But if I had to choose only one, I’m going to say pumpkin. It’s just so creamy and delectable!

  115. Samantha Jean

    I’m a fan of Baked Bree on facebook.

  116. Samantha Jean

    I’m a faof Shabby Apple on facebook.

  117. Samantha Jean

    I also signed up for the Baked Bree newsletter =]

  118. Josephine Law

    mmm. Always down for Banana Cream!

  119. Carol

    I love cherry pie and reading recipes on Baked Bree.

  120. Sarah

    My favorite kind of pie is pecan pie! Thanks for the giveaway!

  121. Sarah

    I’m also subscribed to Baked Bree

  122. JP

    Chocolate pie. Delicious.

  123. JP

    I also liked your FB page!

  124. trisha

    Banana cream…mmmm!

  125. Melissa

    My favorite pie is my Mom’s chocolate cream pie!

  126. Lynne

    I never met a pie I didn’t like and would rather have pie than just about any other dessert.
    Choices, choices….hmmm….blueberry or lemon meringue, coconut cream or strawberry/rhubarb….
    I just can’t decide which one I prefer because it really depends on the day and my mood πŸ™‚
    I am now a fan of Shabby Apple on fb and love the blue dress, I am also a fan of yours on fb and get your blog delivered to my inbox too.
    So sad that this giveaway isn’t open to Canadians because I would love to wear this apron!!

  127. Colleen

    I can’t decide between warm blackberry pie with melting vanilla ice cream or chocolate or coconut cream. A slice of each, perhaps?

  128. Rachel

    I’ve never tried coconut pie, but it sounds amazing especially with the Malibu rum option! also, what is whip it and where would you buy that?
    My favorite pie is pumpkin chiffon pie. So delicious!

  129. juliet

    blueberry cinnamon cardamom pie is my favorite!

  130. Jennifer

    I LOVE coconut cream pie…the only problem is that I am the only one in my household that does. So, I have to settle for lots of lemon and key lime pies! It’s ok, I love them too! Come to think of it, I love ALL pies!!

  131. Kristina Powers

    I love cheesecake, and homemade apple pie!

  132. Carla

    Hands down……………… Banana Cream Pie!

  133. Kristina Powers

    By the way I am also a fan of Both you and the Shabby Apple!

  134. shara

    mmmm… cherry pie!

  135. shara

    fan of baked bree on facebook!

  136. shara

    and… i subscribe to the newsletter! πŸ™‚

  137. MollyC

    My favorite pie would have to be simple strawberry pie : )

  138. Jo-Anna

    This pie looks out of this world amazing! I’m going to have to try it! YUM!

  139. Carrie

    My favorite pie is anything with peanut butter & chocolate!

  140. Ingrid Burton

    Definitely apple pie! Love the aprons, I always wear on when baking, I feel so much more “official”!

  141. heather

    Spiced pear pie is pretty dang amazing.

  142. heather

    Following Baked Bree on Facebook.

  143. Suzannah Martin

    I LOVE Banana Cream Pie. My father-in-law, Bob, makes THE BEST banana cream pies ever! It’s a Martin family favorite AND a Martin family SECRET. I knew I was officially “in” the family a few years ago when Bob divulged his secret recipe to me and even made one with me. Super special and super tasty!
    Thanks for sharing your recipes! We are HUGE fans!! The aprons are beautiful!!
    Thank you,
    Suzannah Martin

  144. Howecafe


  145. Reagan Hernandez

    I have two favorites…the peach pie with the cobbler style topping that you gave me last summer…and Hula pie πŸ™‚ which has coconut, macadamia nuts, and all other kinds of YUM!!

  146. Deb

    I love your website! I would love to wear that fun apron as I make my banoffe pie!
    Mmmmmmmmmm good!!

  147. Rachel

    I’m a fan on Facebook (of both you and Shabby Apple). πŸ™‚

  148. Rachel

    Oh! And my favorite pie is pumpkin. I can not add enough spice to that thing. πŸ˜€

  149. Em Manns

    Apple. Just plain old apple.
    Thanks for your wonderful website! I’m making your chocolate cake (with buttermilk and coffee) this week.

  150. Becky Price


  151. Erin Ledford

    I love Pecan Pie…of course, right?! I am from Texas!!

  152. Danica Evans

    This might be my new favorite! But for now it’s chocolate cream. Chocolate. And cream. Yes.

  153. Anna

    Banana cream pie for sure, but I have never made it. Perhaps you can do a post sometime? Love the coconut cream pie recipe…. I’m going to try to paleo it!

  154. Monica

    My favorite kind of pie is banana cream! Or maybe a chocolate cream… ; )

  155. Monica

    Also already a fan of BakedBree on Facebook! : )

  156. Kristyn

    I love all of your step by step photo instructions! I have to say that it’s a tie between pumpkin & banana cream pie. Yum πŸ™‚

  157. Melanie

    I’m already a Baked Bree follower on FB.

  158. Melanie

    I now follow Shabby Apple.

  159. Betty

    Strawberry Rhubarb!

  160. Grace

    Apple Pie! I absolutely adore your website. The photographs are beautiful and the recipes are the best.

  161. Chantel Elder

    Coconut! You know I will totally give this one a whirl!

  162. Angie

    Pecan pie is my fave!!

  163. Crystal Garcia

    All American Apple Pie!!!

  164. Sheryl

    I am a Baked Bree follower on FB. Love all pies especially chocolate French silk! Yummy!

  165. Sarah

    My favorite is cherry pie…….but after I try this one we will see! πŸ™‚

  166. Tanya Roe

    It is really hard to decide what my favorite pie is…because I LOVE PIES! But, if I had to pick just one, it would have to be coconut cream pie. A “not too sweet” version. I cannot wait to try your recipe here, looks just incredible!

  167. Valerie

    My favorite kind of pie is peach. Mmm…

  168. Allison C

    Thats easy. Hands down strawberry rhubarb is my favorite. I really love the combination and I can’t get enough of it.

  169. Tyla Spielberg

    I love pumpkin pie! Can’t wait to try this reciepe! Sounds amazing.
    I’d loooove an apron πŸ™‚

  170. tamara

    Favorite hmmm berry and I can’t wait to try your coconut cream it’s my husbands favorite. I am also a fan of yours and Shabby Apple

  171. Chris

    I love just a plain ol’ chocolate pudding pie!

  172. Chris

    I am a fan of Baked Bree on Facebook!

  173. Chris

    I am now a fan of Shabby Apple on Facebook!

  174. Anne

    Pumpkin Pie is one of my many favorites – I never commit to “favorite” questions because most things that are a “favorite” can be many for me. Color? Love them all; Toys? Love them all! Food? Impossible!

  175. Miranda

    I love apple pie, it was the first pie, that I learned to make, & I love it.

  176. Brandy Sievers

    Lemon Meringue. Or, French Apple. Or, Key Lime. Or, Strawberry Rhubarb. Or, or, or. πŸ˜‰ I really love Lemon Meringue though. I love tart and sweet together. If only I could get the hang of meringue. Teehee! (already a fan on FB).

  177. MsChilePepper

    My Mama’s peach pie! Its cinnamony peachy goodness still warm from the oven, with a scoop of really good vanilla ice cream. THAT’s summer!

  178. Catherine

    mmmm it is a toss up. Pumpkin in the fall/winter, blackberry in the summer! Both need lots of whipped cream!

  179. Jenny

    Banana cream pie! Nom nom nom!

  180. Henria O.

    Favorite pie? Lemon meringue!

  181. Henria O.

    Like the Baked Bree FB page!

  182. Henria O.

    Like the Shabby Apple FB page!

  183. Henria O.

    Email subscriber!

  184. Cora White

    I am going with strawberry rhubarb pie. It has a very short shelf life. I could use a new apron. Mine is pilfered from my daughter and old.

  185. Cora White

    already a fan of baked bree and i suscribed to the newsletter.

  186. Cora White

    Now a fan of the Shabby Apple on fb.

  187. Kerri

    It’s a seasonal thing – coconut cream pie in the warm months and apple pie in the cool months!

  188. Kerri

    I subscribed to Baked Bree as well!

  189. Stacie H

    My favorite has to be Peach Pie!! YUMMMMYYYY!!!

  190. DoRena Wirgau

    My favorite kind of pie is any kind topped with ice cream!!! If I had to be choosy I’d probably go with good ol’ all American apple. πŸ˜€

  191. DoRena Wirgau

    And I’m a facebook fan of yours!!! I never want to miss a Bree post, they make me smile (and make me hungry!).

  192. DoRena Wirgau

    And I’m a Shabby Apple facebook fan!

  193. Robyn

    I LOVE my mom’s cherry pie. I used to not like cake as a kid (even though I can’t get enough cupcakes!), so it has become a tradition that instead of birthday cake, I get a birthday cherry pie every year!

  194. Anna

    I’m really agonizing over settling on a favorite. Something with chocolate. Banana cream pie w/ chocolate maybe? Or strawberry, preferably with a crumb topping.

  195. Anna

    I’ve just subscribed to your newsletter. Thanks!

  196. lindsay

    so fun!! i love pies…so it is hard to choose just one. i think my favorite is pumpkin! yum!

  197. Kimberly Noble

    I love this recipe for Coconut Cream pie – it may become my favorite. But until I actually put that first bite in my mouth, I am sticking with Pecan Pie! UMMmmmmm. I love it when the pecans are fresh and crunchy, not soggy. Then pumpkin pie, then banana cream pie…….. πŸ™‚ Enjoy your day. You always make mine so pleasant!

  198. amanda

    I think it has to be Derby Pie or Maple Bourbon Pecan Pie. Both with plenty of whipped cream!

  199. laurie

    Brendan (yes the 13 year old boy) makes a delicious chocolate pie!!! It’s definitely a favorite in our house.

  200. Corisa

    Became a fan on Fbook!

  201. Corisa

    My favorite pie has to be Pumpkin because you only have it once a year!

  202. Lori

    I have so many favorites, but on top of my list lately is peach. I recently made one from The Southern Living Cookbook and it was great!

  203. Michelle

    Apple is my absolute favorite, with a great big scoop of vanilla ice cream.

  204. Megan

    Definatly my MIL’s Banana Cream!

  205. Megan

    I “like” baked bree on facebook

  206. Megan

    I “like” shabby apple on facebook

  207. Megan

    I am a subscriber to the Baked Bree newsletter!

  208. Barbara

    Lots to like here today! The kids’ glasses are so cute!
    And coconut cream pie is one of our favorites….love this recipe.
    But my favorite pie? Lemon Angel.

  209. Hannah

    My favorite pie has got to be…key lime pie!! and of course the classic apple pie with ice cream on top. thanks for this giveaway!! πŸ™‚

  210. Amanda

    Favorite pie–Pecan hands down!

  211. Sarah

    Peach is my favorite but strawberry rhubarb takes a close second!

  212. Allison

    Favorite Pie? Well, either Mom’s Chess Pie or YOUR Peanut Butter Pie! Do compliments get me any closer to that lovely apron :)?

  213. Amy

    My favorite pie is either the Tippin’s French Silk or my grandma’s Strawberry Rhubarb!

  214. Amy

    BTW, I hope you continue to enjoy Kansas. Sometimes the weather makes it a little taxing, but it really is a great place.

  215. Daca

    Well, who doesn’t like this pie? To be truth, every pie is perfect. I always vote for homemade recipes, and this one is great.

  216. Mia

    I love lemon meringue pie!!

  217. Mia

    I’m a fan of Baked Bree on FB!

  218. Mia

    I’m a fan of Shabby Apple on FB!

  219. MelodyJ

    I like Peach Pie but really if it’s pie.


  220. Jessica

    I actually love toasted coconut, how perfect! Thanks for all your beautiful recipes!

  221. Denise

    My favorite kind of pie is most definitely pumpkin. Unless we are including apple pie with the crumble and caramel and healthy scoop of vanilla bean on top. That would beat out pumpkin any day..

  222. Denise

    I became a fan of the Shabby apple of Facebook!

  223. Denise

    I became a fan of Baked Bree on Facebook!

  224. Elyse

    My favorite pie is strawberry pie with whipped cream!

  225. Lindsay

    My grandmother always made me a chocolate fudge pie that cannot be beat. Whenever I would go to her house, which unfortunatly was not often, she would always have a fudge pie cooled and ready for me to cut the first sweet piece. Years later she has given me the recipe but it never tastes as good unless she makes it!

  226. Lindsay

    I’m a fan on FB!

  227. Michelle Glenn

    I really truly love Coconut Cream Pie or Chocolate Silk Pie.

  228. Cammie

    Key lime or fresh peach, with peaches plucked from my backyard tree.

  229. Jennifer

    My stepmother’s Chess Pie Divine is, well, divine. I love the recipes handed down from generation to generation!

  230. Trisha

    My mom makes pies for our local farmer’s market- they’re incredible. My favorite is an original of hers- Cherry Almond Crunch. Yum!! πŸ™‚

  231. Cindi Brasher


  232. Stephanie P

    I have to say that my new favorite pie is your peanut butter pie recipe. It was a HIT at a dinner party I recently hosted. I also love a good homemade pot pie though too! MMmmMM thanks for the chance to win such a pretty apron!

  233. Stephanie P

    I’m so excited you have a facebook page. I “liked” you! Did you hear about the parents who named their baby “Like” after the ever-so-popular “like” button??

  234. Brittani

    Love coconut cream pie!

  235. Lois

    My favorite pie would be the one on the plate in front of me….preferably with whipped cream!

  236. Christine

    Definitely banana cream pie from Marie Callender’s! I eat it every year around Christmas when my friends bring it over!

  237. Lorene

    I love pie! Pumpkin, Cherry Streusel, Lemon Meringue, Macadamia Nut…

  238. DoRena Wirgau

    I subscribed to your newsletter. :o)

  239. Mandi Presley

    My favorite is blueberry!

  240. Amy

    I totally have my fingers crossed to win the apron (I don’t own one) so I thought I should mention I am already a fan of Baked Bree on Facebook.

  241. Amy

    And, I already subscribe to the newsletter too. I need to get all of my chances to win in. πŸ™‚

  242. natalie (the sweets life)

    i love all pies, but nothing beats my gma’s apple pie!! πŸ™‚

  243. Simply Gourmet Photography

    My favorite pie is pecan. With pumpkin being a close second. ENJOY!

  244. Shannon

    I’ve always been a BB Facebook fan πŸ™‚

  245. Shannon

    I’m a new Shabby Apple fb fan! How did it take me this long?

  246. Shannon

    Just signed up for the newsletter! Can’t wait for the cookbook! πŸ™‚

  247. Shannon

    My favorite pie is pumpkin. I know it’s seasonal but there’s just nothing like it with fresh whipped cream!

  248. Stephanie riley

    Would you believe that wildberry pie IS my favorite! Have to say peach is a close second. A la mode for summer. yummy.

  249. Jamie

    Pumpkin pie

  250. Mandi

    I’m going to go with Dutch Apple Pie… LOVE the crumbly topping!!

  251. deb christensen

    ok, until yesterday my favorite pie has always been peach. but yesterday I made your peanut butter pie for the first time. oh my skippy! the boys went nuts. like I would if I won that apron.

  252. ericamarvel

    Your photography is beautiful! I can’t wait to try this out!

  253. Angela

    Anything with chocolate! Lemon meringue pie is a close second, though.

  254. Majica Phillips

    lemon meringue!! And the apron is awesome too.

  255. pamm

    I have two favorites, Pumpkin and Banana Cream.

  256. Jacqueline Snell

    I’d have to say that my favorite pie is chocolate pie with graham cracker crust. This pie is a family tradition served only at Thanksgiving and Christmas Eve. My grandma used to always make it and my sister and I would put on the whipped cream and chocolate shavings. IT is delicious and it is nostalgic. Chocolate pie mmmm…..

  257. Jacqueline Snell

    I am a fan of yours:) I have been for a while!

  258. Jacqueline Snell

    I’m a shabby apple fan! Thanks for letting us know about it!

  259. Melissa Armijo

    #1 Pumpkin Pie!

  260. Melissa Armijo

    #2 Like you on FB

  261. Melissa Armijo

    #3 Liked Shabby Apple on FB

  262. Dawn

    Love my mom’s walnut pie, especially when she is visiting and makes it for one of our holiday dinners. It just tastes better when SHE makes it. πŸ™‚ Can’t wait to try this coconut pie recipe. Yuuuuum!~

  263. Renee

    I will make this pie pronto! Yum! Pick me, pick me!!

  264. Renee

    Okay, so didn’t read the instructions! Favorite pie – apple crumb!

  265. katy

    Blueberry cobbler! Does that count? You can’t beat a big slice of cobbler with a mounding scoop of ice cream

  266. samantha

    So many choices for pie. Although one one my favs is Marie calendars German Chocolate. SO good. Followed by cherry pie. Yum!!

  267. samantha

    Fan of yours!

  268. samantha

    Fan of shabby Apple!

  269. Amanda Thompson

    My favorite pie would have to be Chocolate Pecan!

  270. Amanda Thompson

    I subscribe to the Baked Bree newsletter πŸ™‚

  271. Suzanne Brown

    My favorite pie is my Mother’s apple pie – blueberry is a close second!

  272. Sheila

    My favorite pie is a toss up between a berry pie and key lime pie.

  273. Lyndee

    Thank you thank you!! Can’t wait for the apron!

    1. bakedbree

      you are welcome. I sent you an email a little while ago about it.

  274. Kari


    LOVE your blog and I made this pie this weekend. It was amazing πŸ™‚

    1. bakedbree

      So glad Kari! I love this pie too.

  275. Sheila

    I realize this post is quite dated, but I made this pie today and am wondering what I did wrong. While it tasted delicious, the custard really wasn’t set all that well. I did everything to a T, except after the custard comes to a boil, it doesn’t specify how long to let it thicken, or what stage it should resemble in thickness…this is the first custard ie I’ve made and wasn’t sure, but from the pudding-like ooze I have, clearly is wasn’t enough.

    1. bakedbree

      It needs to come to a full bubble, and it continues to thicken as it chills. A good test is to dip a wooden spoon into the custard and drag your finger down the back of the spoon, if the custard keeps its shape, it should be thick enough.

  276. Pingback: Coconut Cream Pie with a Coconut Cookie Crust Recipe | Barbara Bakes

Leave a Reply