I have searched high and low for the perfect sugar cookie recipe. It took years to find. I had to kiss a lot of frogs to find this recipe. I love it for a few reasons. 1) It makes a ton of cookies. 2) It rolls out like a dream. 3) They taste really good. I have used this recipe for so many different occasions. The photo above is from Christmas, but I have used it for Halloween, Valentine’s Day and just because it is a Wednesday. This recipe can easily be halved. I usually make the whole thing and freeze half.
Cream together the butter and sugar until it is really light and fluffy. Add the eggs and the vanilla and butter extracts. Add the dry ingredients and mix until well.
Lick the beater.
Lick it again for good measure.
Wrap the dough in plastic wrap and chill for at least 3-4 hours or overnight.
Roll the dough out and cut using your favorite cookie cutter.
Bake the cookies in a 350 degree oven for 8-10 minutes. Do not brown the edges. I like this glaze recipe to decorate. These are great. Make a bunch. Share them and this recipe with all of your friends.
Cream together the butter and sugar until it is really light and fluffy. Add the eggs and the vanilla and butter extracts. Add the dry ingredients and mix until well.
Wrap the dough in plastic wrap and chill for at least 3-4 hours or overnight.
Roll the dough out and cut using your favorite cookie cutter.
Bake the cookies in a 350 degree oven for 8-10 minutes. Do not brown the edges.
Success! Now check your email to confirm your subscription.
It is hard to say because it depends on the size of your cutter, but usually it fills 4 cooling racks full of cookies. I would say about 6 dozen normal size cookies?
PERFECT!!! Please publish your frosting recipie – and how much dye and when to add sprinkles and are the cookies completely cool or slightly warm and Thank YOU!
I had to come back to make sure the recipe I have in my recipe book is the “prince”. I like that the edges stay white/ or the color of the dye when you bake them!
Thank you so much for sharing your recipe, I made some Xmas cookies with my 3yr old daughter and it was a hit! Super easy and so good! I just wish we didn’t have to wait 3hrs ( it’s a lifetime to a eager 3yr old baker)! This is now our go to cookie recipe for all occasions! 🙂 happy holidays & god bless!
Threw away most of the dough awful to roll out when refrigerated…the taste of the cookie is not that good..maybe when I add icing they will be better..
Made these cookies last evening and this will be my go to recipe. The dough is not at all fragile and very easy to move from cutting surface to cookie sheet. Love them. Thanks so much for sharing.
These are PERFECT. Perfect, perfect, perfect. I cannot stress that enough. They were a little tough to roll out, but not terrible. They taste amazing and they hold their shape incredibly. Thank you for sharing this recipe!
Thank you! This is my all time favorite recipe for sugar cookies. Did you let the dough sit for a bit before you tried rolling it out? That might make it easier to roll.
I made two batches of this today, and I am so sad about how it is turning out. The first batch I added all 7 cups of flour right away, and it could not be more dry. It is just little crumble balls. I still squished it together the best I could and refrigerated it. I took it out to roll it, and it’s been sitting out for over an hour and still HARD as a rock! I finally got it to roll a little – and it just crumbled to nothing.
The second batch I only added 6 cups of flour and the texture of the dough was much better. I just took that batch out of the fridge since I threw the other away, so I guess we’ll see how it is to roll in a couple hours.
I’ve never had a recipe from you go this poorly! And from previous comments, some people don’t have issues with it so I’m wondering what the issue is! Hope the cookies make up for the frustrating day of baking them! 🙂
That doesn’t sound right. I have made these cookies hundreds of times, and I have never had this happen to me. I am so sorry, I know how frustrating that can be!
The cookies DEFINITELY redeemed themselves! Oh my goodness are they AMAZING. Honestly the PERFECT sugar cookie. Hold their shape perfectly, but stay softish… And the taste is so good.
I’m making another batch today 🙂
And for me, I guess the key is only 6 cups of flour!
I made these cookies for Valentines Day, and they were fantastic! I didn’t have butter, so I used margarine instead, and they turned out beautifully. I added a little extra flour to the dough ( about a 1/2 cup) and used a little flour to roll them out so they wouldn’t stick, and that seemed to help them keep their shape better during baking. I rolled the cookies out about a 1/4″ thick, baked them 8 minutes on an insulated cookie sheet and ended up with 5 dozen cookies. I will never use another sugar cookie recipe again!
Just made these today, and they turned out great! The texture was perfect for making cut-outs. I rolled the dough out to 1/4″ thick and they cooked for exactly 8 minutes. I am excited to serve them at Easter, and am sure my family will love them! Thanks for the recipe!
I made these for my daughters birthday. I made number 1’s they were awesome , perfect not a single problem. And they were the best tasting ones I’ve had. Thank you for the recipe ps. They held up wonderfully during the decorating process.
Have you ever frozen the dough and then used it later? Just wondering, if so, how that worked out. I am wanting to make this early for Valentine’s Day cookie decor party with my kids. Thanks.
I have been using this recipe since 1969 when I was married. Our family tradition at Christmas was to make these cookies and we would have a ball decorating them, even the girls’ dad. Both my daughters carry on the tradition with their kids. Great family bonding.
Just wanted to say thanks for this recipe! I’ve been using it now for a couple of years for our neighborhood holiday cookie decorating parties and it’s always worked great.
I am so glad! This is my favorite sugar cookie recipe and I always come back to it. It always works and tastes really good. I am so happy that it has become a tradition for you too.
This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.
You can adjust all of your cookie settings by navigating the tabs on the left hand side.
Strictly Necessary Cookies
Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.
If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.
Print
Pin
The cookies look perfect and what cute photos!
two quick questions: 1) what temp did you bake them at? 2) parchment paper on cookie sheet? Thanks!
Hey! Great looking cookies! I was wondering though, how many cookies does this make approximately? It looks like a huge amount!
It is hard to say because it depends on the size of your cutter, but usually it fills 4 cooling racks full of cookies. I would say about 6 dozen normal size cookies?
What temperature do you bake these at? Thanks!
350. I will fix the post. Thanks for letting me know.
PERFECT!!! Please publish your frosting recipie – and how much dye and when to add sprinkles and are the cookies completely cool or slightly warm and Thank YOU!
I will do that. I am going to try to make a video also.
Can you share your icing recipe for these as well? Thanks a bunch.
I am always looking for new recipes for sugar cookies. Can you tell me if these are soft?
Not really soft. They are really good for cut out cookies. It also depends on how thick you roll them out too.
I really like to make these, but I only have Vanilla essence. Can I use that instead of vanilla extract, and how much?
Yes, but I have no idea how much. A Tablespoon?
I had to come back to make sure the recipe I have in my recipe book is the “prince”. I like that the edges stay white/ or the color of the dye when you bake them!
I love this recipe Joanne, I have tried a few others and always come back to this one.
what happens if i don’t chill the dough? i know it’s a big to-do in the preparation, ’cause i heard some don’t need it, is it really not needed?
It is needed when you cut the dough. It helps the cookie retain their shape.
Would this recipe also work for slice and bake?
It should be just fine.
Can I use reg butter and cut down on the salt or can I use crisco?
Yes, but I would not use Crisco.
I only have salted butter, so just to clarify — can I just swap salted for unsalted, or do I also need to omit or reduce the salt? Thanks!
I would half the salt.
Thank you! You’re so sweet to reply!
Hey! 🙂 Looks like a great recipe. But are they still kind of sweet without frosting? My SO doesnt like frosting so yeah~
Yes, but not overly.
How much butter is 2 cups (in grams)?
Please use a cup to gram converter. Google it and you will find many options.
I tried these, added everything but too dry and crumbly 🙁 not sure what happened
I am not sure either. Made you forgot an egg?
Thank you so much for sharing your recipe, I made some Xmas cookies with my 3yr old daughter and it was a hit! Super easy and so good! I just wish we didn’t have to wait 3hrs ( it’s a lifetime to a eager 3yr old baker)! This is now our go to cookie recipe for all occasions! 🙂 happy holidays & god bless!
thank you! I love this dough and have been making it for years. I hope that you will be making it for years too!
Threw away most of the dough awful to roll out when refrigerated…the taste of the cookie is not that good..maybe when I add icing they will be better..
Sorry, I have never had a problem with this dough and I have been making it for years.
Made these cookies last evening and this will be my go to recipe. The dough is not at all fragile and very easy to move from cutting surface to cookie sheet. Love them. Thanks so much for sharing.
I am so glad! I love this recipe. I have tried others and always come back to this one.
These are PERFECT. Perfect, perfect, perfect. I cannot stress that enough. They were a little tough to roll out, but not terrible. They taste amazing and they hold their shape incredibly. Thank you for sharing this recipe!
Thank you! This is my all time favorite recipe for sugar cookies. Did you let the dough sit for a bit before you tried rolling it out? That might make it easier to roll.
I made two batches of this today, and I am so sad about how it is turning out. The first batch I added all 7 cups of flour right away, and it could not be more dry. It is just little crumble balls. I still squished it together the best I could and refrigerated it. I took it out to roll it, and it’s been sitting out for over an hour and still HARD as a rock! I finally got it to roll a little – and it just crumbled to nothing.
The second batch I only added 6 cups of flour and the texture of the dough was much better. I just took that batch out of the fridge since I threw the other away, so I guess we’ll see how it is to roll in a couple hours.
I’ve never had a recipe from you go this poorly! And from previous comments, some people don’t have issues with it so I’m wondering what the issue is! Hope the cookies make up for the frustrating day of baking them! 🙂
That doesn’t sound right. I have made these cookies hundreds of times, and I have never had this happen to me. I am so sorry, I know how frustrating that can be!
The cookies DEFINITELY redeemed themselves! Oh my goodness are they AMAZING. Honestly the PERFECT sugar cookie. Hold their shape perfectly, but stay softish… And the taste is so good.
I’m making another batch today 🙂
And for me, I guess the key is only 6 cups of flour!
I am so glad!
I made these cookies for Valentines Day, and they were fantastic! I didn’t have butter, so I used margarine instead, and they turned out beautifully. I added a little extra flour to the dough ( about a 1/2 cup) and used a little flour to roll them out so they wouldn’t stick, and that seemed to help them keep their shape better during baking. I rolled the cookies out about a 1/4″ thick, baked them 8 minutes on an insulated cookie sheet and ended up with 5 dozen cookies. I will never use another sugar cookie recipe again!
I am so glad! I love this recipe too. I have tried others, but always come back to this one.
Just made these today, and they turned out great! The texture was perfect for making cut-outs. I rolled the dough out to 1/4″ thick and they cooked for exactly 8 minutes. I am excited to serve them at Easter, and am sure my family will love them! Thanks for the recipe!
I love this recipe too. I cannot use another because I know that it is so good.
Hey, Bree! Question: What is the size of the eggs? Small, Medium or Large? I hope you reply..
I use large eggs.
are these soft and chewy or hard? im looking for soft cookies.
They are in between. They are soft in the middle, but made for decorating, so they need to be sturdy.
I made these for my daughters birthday. I made number 1’s they were awesome , perfect not a single problem. And they were the best tasting ones I’ve had. Thank you for the recipe ps. They held up wonderfully during the decorating process.
I am so glad. I have tried other recipes, but this is the one that I always come back to.
They look great! When you are making half recipe, how many eggs do you use? Thanks!
Well, half of 4 is 2. I’d use 2.
Hahahahaha! I was completely sure I read 3 eggs in the recipe! Sorry!!
No problem, I thought that I had missed something. 🙂
Have you ever frozen the dough and then used it later? Just wondering, if so, how that worked out. I am wanting to make this early for Valentine’s Day cookie decor party with my kids. Thanks.
All the time. I usually freeze half of the dough and use it another time. It makes A LOT of dough.
Our church asks us to make cookies for the prisoners and I always struggle with an easy peasy recipe. This one will go down a treat.
This is the best sugar cookie recipe I’ve tried, and I’ve tried a lot. It tastes great, and is easy to roll out.
I have been using this recipe since 1969 when I was married. Our family tradition at Christmas was to make these cookies and we would have a ball decorating them, even the girls’ dad. Both my daughters carry on the tradition with their kids. Great family bonding.
★★★★★
I love traditions like that. 🙂
Do you have a frosting recipe you recommend?
Yup! This one. https://bakedbree.wpengine.com/sugar-cookie-glaze
Hi Bree,
Just wanted to say thanks for this recipe! I’ve been using it now for a couple of years for our neighborhood holiday cookie decorating parties and it’s always worked great.
~Kate
I am so glad! This is my favorite sugar cookie recipe and I always come back to it. It always works and tastes really good. I am so happy that it has become a tradition for you too.