Key Lime Pie

This week I am going to do a series on Hosting a Dinner Party and Still Enjoy Your Guests. Whew, long title I know. I explain myself in the video but I will give a quick overview here as well. I love to have people over for dinner and do it all the time. The whole reason that I have people over is because I want to see them, not spend my evening in the kitchen. So this week, I am cooking an entire meal (we call this Greek Feast, it is one of my all time favorite meals ever. Easy, delicious, and healthy) that is a perfect menu for a summer (anytime really) get together. You can make almost everything ahead of time. All week long I will give you some tips and tricks on how to throw a party that your guests will ooh and ahh over. At the end of the week, I will give you a printable shopping list and a game plan so that you can create this meal at your home.

TIPWhen I start my cooking for a dinner party, I usually always make the dessert first. Desserts can almost always be made ahead of time. I like having an entire course checked off my list so that cooking the rest of the meal doesn’t seem like such a big task. If you do a little bit each day, by the time your party rolls around, you only have to make the last minute things and everything else is done.

key lime pie recipe

This is an untraditional Key Lime Pie. Most Key Lime Pie recipes have sweetened condensed milk in them and this one does not. It probably should be called Lime Curd Pie, but let’s not be picky. This recipe comes from my Nonnie and it is my brother’s favorite dessert and a top 5 for my husband. This is a great dessert for a party (or to bring to party) because you can make everything ahead of time and it will keep in the fridge for about 4 days without the whipped cream. If you stabilize the whipped cream, you can do the entire dessert the day before.

I also cannot always find key limes at my grocery store. Use regular limes. I won’t tell, if you don’t tell.

how to make graham cracker crust

Make your graham cracker crust. This one is 1 1/2 cups graham cracker crumbs, 1/2 cup sugar, and 6 Tablespoons of melted butter. I give detailed instructions here. Bake the crust in a 375 degree oven for about 9 minutes.

key lime pie recipe

graham cracker crust
4 eggs
1 cup sugar
3/4 cup key lime juice
1/2 cup butter cut into small pieces
1 teaspoon gelatin, softened
1 lime zested
whipped cream

key lime pie recipe

In the top of a double boiler (I don’t have one, so I use a saucepan filled halfway with water and a large metal bowl on top) combine the sugar, eggs, and lime juice.

key lime pie recipe

Whisk constantly over medium heat. When the mixture starts to thicken, add one piece of butter at a time. Whisk constantly until the butter has melted. Add one piece at a time until you have added all of the butter. The lime curd will be thick.

key lime pie recipe

Add the softened gelatin (I sprinkle the teaspoon of gelatin over some water, 2 Tablespoons maybe until it has dissolved) to the lime mixture.

key lime pie recipe

Strain your lime mixture to guarantee that there are no egg pieces in your lime curd.

key lime pie recipe

Add the lime zest.

key lime pie recipe

Pour the lime curd into the cooled crust. Let chill for at least 3 hours before serving to let the filling set up. Garnish with whipped cream and extra lime zest.

key lime pie recipe

This is a gorgeous and refreshing summer dessert. One that people will beg for the recipe for.

key lime pie recipe

See you tomorrow to start on the next part of our Dinner Party Series.

key lime pie recipe

Key Lime Pie

Yield: serves 8
Prep Time: 30 minutes
Cook Time: 20 minutes
Additional Time: 3 hours
Total Time: 3 hours 50 minutes

Key Lime Pie made without sweetened condensed milk. A graham cracker crust filled with key lime curd and topped with freshly whipped cream.

Ingredients

  • graham cracker crust
  • 4 eggs
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 3/4 cup key lime juice
  • 1/2 cup butter cut into small pieces
  • 1 teaspoon gelatin, softened
  • 1 lime zested
  • whipped cream

Instructions

  1. In the top of a double boiler (I don’t have one, so I use a saucepan filled halfway with water and a large metal bowl on top) combine the sugar, eggs, and lime juice.
  2. Whisk constantly over medium heat. When the mixture starts to thicken, add one piece of butter at a time. Whisk constantly until the butter has melted. Add one piece at a time until you have added all of the butter. The lime curd will be thick.
  3. Add the softened gelatin (I sprinkle the teaspoon of gelatin over some water, 2 Tablespoons maybe until it has dissolved) to the lime mixture.
  4. Strain your lime mixture to guarantee that there are no egg pieces in your lime curd.
  5. Add the lime zest.
  6. Pour the lime curd into the cooled crust. Let chill for at least 3 hours before serving to let the filling set up. Garnish with whipped cream and extra lime zest.
Nutrition Information:
Yield: 10 Serving Size: 1
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 286Total Fat: 16gSaturated Fat: 7gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 7gCholesterol: 99mgSodium: 189mgCarbohydrates: 34gFiber: 0gSugar: 24gProtein: 4g

All information and tools presented and written within this site are intended for informational purposes only.

bree-hester-small.jpg

Oh hey there!

Well, hello there! I’m Bree Hester, the Boston-based blogger and food photographer here at Baked Bree. Here you can get lots of weeknight meal inspiration, eat more plant-based meals, and still indulge in a decadent sweet treat. Baked Bree is a place where you will find great recipes and inspiration for your next family adventure.

raspberry orange pistachio ricotta cake slices on a wire rack

Don’t Miss a Thing!

The newsletter you can’t wait to read. Best enjoyed with a beverage and a snack.Β 

Enter your email address below to join my list and receive my weekly Friday newsletter and new blog posts.

White Chocolate Banana Bread

This Post Has 60 Comments

  1. Nancy Grundel

    WOW!!! Key Lime pie is one of my all time favorite desserts! I have to try your recipe for sure!! Thanks, Nancy

    1. bakedbree

      I hope that you like it Nancy!

  2. Azurede

    Love your recipe and wonderful instructions with beautiful photos. Thank you!

    1. bakedbree

      You are most welcome!

  3. Memoria

    I have NEVER hosted a party because I’m too much of an introvert. However, whenever comes the time that I feel up to hosting a small party, I will keep your tips in mind. I’m looking forward to this series.

    The pie looks absolutely perfect. I love how high the crust is and the lovely look of the zest and whipped cream. You’re amazing, Bree!

    1. bakedbree

      You are too sweet to me. You have never had party? With all of the amazingness that comes out of your kitchen? Have one party and I bet that you will feel differently about it. Where do you live?

  4. Sarah

    This pie looks absolutely delicious, and I love your photos!

    1. bakedbree

      thank you!

  5. Magic of Spice

    A perfect pie! Love your tips too…but this pie:) Also love your step by step photos…

    1. bakedbree

      thank you.

  6. Tessa

    Loved the video! I’m excited to see what’s next for the rest of the week. I’m only 19 and have a tiny apartment complete with 2 dining chairs so hosting a dinner party isn’t in my near future but I still love the thought of entertaining πŸ™‚

    The pie looks so creamy and refreshing!

    1. bakedbree

      I used to have parties when I was in college all the time. They were some of the most fun parties. Eating on the floor with paper plates and cheap beer. You can totally pull it off.

  7. Nam (The Culinary Chronicles)

    I just love LIME and this Key Lime Pie looks absolutely DELISH!

    1. bakedbree

      It is one of my favorites. Hope that you like it just as much.

  8. Amanda

    Hi Bree. Nice to meet you! I found you from Tara’s blog and LOVE your pictures!! She did some for us 2 years ago and I still love them. Your cooking blog is great and I am so excited to hear all about this yummy Greek feast!

    1. bakedbree

      Isn’t Tara wonderful? I love my pictures so much. They will always remind me of that day and the trip that we took.

  9. Betty

    This pie looks so delicious! Your photos are beautiful- If only I could reach into this computer screen and pull out one of those slices! Key lime pie is one of my favorite summer desserts- thanks for sharing πŸ™‚

    1. bakedbree

      Thank you! I love Key Lime Pie too… this is a good one.

  10. patty

    hi there – i tried to make the key lime pie…i did something wrong as it didn’t set right…it didn’t really harden…i did the 1 teaspoon of gelatin to 2 tablespoons of water…any ideas?

    1. bakedbree

      It should be soft set, if you add too much gelatin, it will look and act like jello. I know because I have done this before. You want just enough gelatin to hold it together. Maybe add a touch more gelatin.

  11. Kaitlin

    I made this for some friends today and it went over SO well! Wonderful recipe – thank you for sharing!

    1. bakedbree

      you are very welcome. Glad that you liked it.

  12. MsNJohnson

    The pie looks delicious!! The recipe I generally use does not require eggs but I will have to give this one a try. I love how you display each step in the cooking process. Oh how I love the simplicities of life…

    1. bakedbree

      Glad that you like it, I hope that you will continue to read.

  13. CJ Morrison

    I love Key Lime pie but hate condensed milk. i have make them without condensed milk and try to get real key limes. i like your the way your recipe reads and i am going to try it this weekend. thanks so much.. it is one of my favorite pies.

    1. bakedbree

      me too! I just use plain limes. I cannot always get key limes when I need them.

  14. CJ Morrison

    i am going to use stabilized whipping cream

    1. bakedbree

      It is a good idea, then you pie will look pretty longer.

  15. Julie

    Hi Bree – You mentioned this desert was top 5 of your husband’s. I was just wondering what the other 4 might be. Looking forward to trying your yummy key lime recipe. Cheers, Julie.

    1. bakedbree

      He is not a big dessert person, but he does like a few things. Peanut Butter Pie is his all-time favorite. He loves a chocolate milk shake, a good chewy brownie, and a chocolate chip cookie. He is pretty boring.

  16. Julie

    PS: My hubby’s favorite dessert is burnt (yes, as in blackened) chocolate chip cookies. Go figure.

    1. bakedbree

      Wow! That is random.

  17. Anna Picardi

    Hi I was looking for an alternative to making a Key Lime Pie without sweetened condensed milk and found your recipe. I have made it 3 times. The first time it was perfect delicous and refreshing. I live in Florida and used fresh Key Limes. The next two times I adjusted the amount of Gelatin which was fun, using more Gelatin makes a firmer filling so you can cut it into squares and here in Florida where everything melts in minutes it was perfect for a picnic. My perfect mix is one and a half tsp of Gelatin to two tsp of water. My chilren tease me that I am a bad baker so being able to cook this on the stovetop kept me from being teased haha. A devine recipe, fun refreshing and easy to make!! Thank you so much Anna

    1. bakedbree

      I am glad that you like it so much, and am jealous of the fresh key limes.

  18. Emi Reiner

    Thanks for this recipe. I love your photos. I was going to make this pie for company tonight, but forgot the condensed milk, so I am happy to have found this. I only have bottled key lime juice, hope that’s ok. Emi

    1. bakedbree

      You are welcome Emi! I love this pie, it is so fresh tasting.

  19. jess

    Hello! I was just wondering why the gelatin is necessary. I’d love to make this recipe since pretty much everything else has condensed milk in it! I just don’t have gelatin on hand so I was wondering if it could go without, or if it is a necessary! Thank You!

    1. bakedbree

      It probably will not set without the gelatin. It is essentially a lime curd pie, and the gelatin is what holds it all together.

  20. Melissa

    I, too, am very excited to have a recipe without the canned milk. Do you also have a replacement for gelatin? I don’t seem to have any…

    1. bakedbree

      No, you need the gelatin to make it hold.

      1. christina

        Can you use Lime Jello in place of the Gelatin.

        1. bakedbree

          I don’t think so. I mean, you could, but I think that it would really take away from this recipe.

  21. Amanda

    This was truly wonderful! I am working on building my skills in the kitchen and this made me feel like a “boss” it was so good πŸ˜‰

    1. bakedbree

      I am so glad, I love this recipe too. It is my husband’s favorite too.

  22. Emma

    Thank you for this post! I was going to make key lime pie but forgot about evaporated milk! thanks for the recipe and the great step by step pictures to go with it.

    1. bakedbree

      You are welcome!

  23. Rob Stathem

    Wow, such great recipes here! I may just have to try them all. I’m a major foodie and food photographer as well and it’s fun—fun to cook and try new things and then photograph those creations!

    Thank you, Bree, for this delicious looking recipe! Key Lime Pie is the perfect treat on a hot day! I will bookmark this and try this next summer, or, knowing me I’ll cook it now and eat the whole thing!! LOL!

    1. bakedbree

      Thank you Rob, this pie is amazing!

  24. Rachel

    I just made this pie! It’s chilling right now! 3 more hours till I can eat it. Can’t wait!

    1. bakedbree

      Jealous!!

  25. Marko

    What size pan did you use, cause I really wanna make this!!!

    1. bakedbree

      I used a pie plate. 8-9 inches? It doesn’t make much of a difference in this recipe.

  26. Nancy

    Can you substitute cornstarch for gelatin? Kosher reasons prevent me from using gelatin

    1. bakedbree

      I’ve never made it that way. It is essentially a citrus curd, so I would look for a similar recipe using cornstarch and change the flavors.

    2. Andrew

      I can’t do it with regular limes. It doesn’t taste anything like a key lime pie. Two totally different flavor profiles otherwise the recipe is great. Like the use of gelatin

      1. Bree Hester

        Then don’t do it. I can’t always get key limes.

  27. Melissa

    I am a real good blogger and was having quite a time finding a good recipe for key lime pie. Thank you for posting this!! I bet I have made this pie a dozen times, and I get raves every time πŸ™‚

    1. bakedbree

      It’s the best one I’ve ever had.

  28. Pingback: The Best Peanut Butter Pie Recipe Ever | Baked Bree

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.